Kurzübersicht

Screenshots

Videos

Kommentare

Kommentar von 75419

Still need a Seal to Judge - and that Seal will still effect Judging damage, just not the utility

Kommentar von 201933

Doesn't eat the seal anymore. :)

Kommentar von 571637

I don't know if any of you mentioned this, the damage caused by the Judgements is changed depending on the seal used.

Kommentar von 195790

In patch 4.0.1 the differing Judgements (Light, Wisdom, Justice) have been removed and once again there is just a single Judgement (as it used to be in the beginning). However one of the major changes to Judgement is that it no longer places a "heal-on-hit" debuff on the target.

You never noticed how much that was healing you during your quest farming until it's gone.

Kommentar von 90859

Am I missing something and/or being dumb? Judging now does not put any kind of debuff on the target, at least for Holy, correct? So, why does the T8/9 holy 2-piece bonus still increase the duration of our judgments?

Kommentar von guatafu

Unlike most spells you don't need to be facing the target to cast this.

Kommentar von 803227

Anyone else surprised by the questionable spelling choice? 'Judgement' is a valid spelling, but only in UK and Australian English; and even in the UK, formal or traditional texts continue to use 'judgment' (e.g., Bible, legal docs). The spelling is always 'judgment' in US English and most often in Canadian English as well. Since the game seems to be in US English, and in US English 'judgement' is a straight-up misspelling (yeah, you could probably find examples of it, but it definitely wouldn't slip past any self-respecting newspaper editor), this seems like a mistake to me, unless Blizzard is into mixing US and UK English haphazardly, wikipedia style.

Okay, I realize no one cares. If I were a stronger person, I would have been able to fight the urge to post about a typo in a video game.

Kommentar von Tontel

I'm just going to leave this here for a while.

English is English. My nickname is Grey, and I'm an American.

Edit: As for the reason I came here, does this still use melee hit%? I saw no real confirmation, post-cata.
Oh, dear. Brackets are hard.

Edit2: Testing commencing...

We all have weaknesses - mine appears to be oversimiplication (and generalization!).

Kommentar von 803227

I like the video, Tontel. I'm acquainted with the concepts of hyper-correction and descriptive rather than prescriptive language. I prefer descriptive lexicography, like most people do today. But my case was descriptive -- Blizzard's use is anomalous in context. That may change with time, if their spelling takes off in American English (I don't quite agree with the oversimplification 'English is English,' although I think you're making a fair point). I can deal with it, I just couldn't resist mentioning it, and hopefully you can forgive me.

As for your real question ... I don't know anything about wow :(

Kommentar von 838694

I have a question about this spell post cata... does judgement really give mana back anymore? I know it USED to, however if I go by the spell details, it now only does damage with no mana regen mentioned. If it does still give mana back, can someone tell me WHERE it says this? Thank you.

Kommentar von 624455

Blizz, how could you spell judgment wrong...
Thanks for the correction, Serf. I always thought it could only be spelled one way, at least that what MS Word thinks...
Instead of downrating the comment that led to a little bit of learning, I've decided to uprate your comment! I mean, who would've thought of something like that!

Kommentar von 137356

I believe in 4.2 Blizzard changed attacks to auto target and to begin harming... which hurts if you spam judgement cause you're now grabbing far off mobs in dungeons by accident. I know that just means spammers need to be cautious.

But more so, does anyone know of a successful macro that can eliminate something like /startattack which seems to be on our attacks now, without clearing your current target?

Kommentar von Species3259

I just had a conversation with a GM regarding this 'spell' because i noticed that i could actually miss with my Judgement although i have the passive Sheath of Light as a retri.

It seems that mechanical wise the 'ranged' melee hit cap is used for this spell.
The same mechanic applies to the ability Hammer of Wrath.

So apparently only Exorcism, Holy Wrath and Consecration make use of the spell hit cap.

Kommentar von 680985

In response to Metaxo's comment, "In patch 4.0.1 the differing Judgements (Light, Wisdom, Justice) have been removed and once again there is just a single Judgement (as it used to be in the beginning). However one of the major changes to Judgement is that it no longer places a "heal-on-hit" debuff on the target."

Just to let you know though, it's not gone, you just have to use Seal of Insight, as it gives you hp AND mana back.

Kommentar von Ronark

Looks as if the name was nerfed in Mists of Pandaria.

Kommentar von Thottbot

That's exactly why they need to make the judgements more worthwhile...like by completely revamping JoC and making JoR dish out at least 200% more damage

Kommentar von Thottbot

The Judgement of Righteousness at Rank 8 only does a one time 133 damage. Hence, the Judgement icon doesn't appear on your target. Seal of Righteousness at Rank 8 is 66 damage per weapon strike. You best bet is to not judge the Seal Righteousness ever. Unless your doing it with a judgement/seal combination such as Judgement of Righteousness and Seal of Command.

Kommentar von Thottbot

sigh...the majority of our judgements are useless, and the seal/judgement system is flawed in that the micro management and time required to use it makes it woefully ineffective in PvP. I've already posted how each seal and its respective judgement could (and should) be improved, because as they are right now, they are all underpowered. Even though no one uses JoC, the damage it provides is actually superior to SoR when used in cojenction w/ SoJ and should be used in place of SoR because 1) its proc rate is based on a "proc per minute" system, thereby granting its user a "proc per swing" value nearly equal to SoR if he/she uses a slow weapon, and 2) the damage JoC deals still ocurrs even when the target temporarily becomes immune to the stun for 15 sec after the first stun form SoJ, due to a PvP limitation called "diminishing returns". The JoC/SoJ combo is incredibly effective against casters, and is probably more effective against them then just smaking them with SoC procs...ppl are afraid to use it because of dimishing returns--even tho they don't become immune its damage...this combo, tho it costs more mana to activate, is far superior to SoR and its worthless judgement. (...and btw I fail to see how using JoR and then SoC forms a combo...they don't seem to relate to eachother at all).

Kommentar von Thottbot

yeah, sure this is great...no its perfect, just F**k'n perfect. Right after I let everyone know about the JoC+SoJ combo in that one can out damage SoR at the cost of additional mana because JoC still deals damage even after the target becomes immune to stuns, Bilzzard descides that this is an exploit and developes an "emergency hotfix" to correct the supposed "problem"...and now because of it, JoC can no longer damage when immune to stuns and is even more useless then before. Lol, this is complete BS. Bilz must have been like, "Oh noes, he said it would be effective against casters--and that means pallies can actually do damage to shamans! We'd better nerf this before the Alliance actually starts winning on BG!" Seeing as how Blizzard would be inclined to "fix" this rather than fix the "spell not ready" bug of SoC makes me worry that 1.9 is gonna be more of a nerf than a buff. Tho my only intention is to help the paladin class and provide potential improvements, this has got to be my fault...but it also leads me to believe that Blizz has read some of my comments--so plz, Blizzard, for the love of God and all that is holy, consider some of my improvements if u are intending to actually BUFF the pally in any way, shape or form, come 1.9!

Kommentar von Thottbot

Rather than wait for blizzard to fix paladins, I switched to holy. I'm not doing monster crits, but with improved SoR,improved JoCr, uninterruptable heals+ mana refund on crit heals every 2 min, I'm owning horde 1v2 or 1v3- Sometimes without cooldowns (oh and benediction)

Kommentar von Thottbot

You can't level up with judgement..

Kommentar von Thottbot

What is base mana?
Is this your mana before armor, and buffs, or your mana after armor, but before buffs or after armor and buffs?

If int from armor increases the cost of your judgements, its not worth getting armor with int on it (considering whether or not you use judgements alot in your build).

May as well just get valor and some regen/spirit items :p

Kommentar von Thottbot

The Heart and soul of the Paladin, well... I guess Seals are more important. I find Judgment/Holy Spec. the best personally, you can help this spell get easier on your mana, do some good damage, and still be good in parties.

Kommentar von Thottbot

I know that this isn't really related but at 39 would i do more damage with pendulum of doom as retribution spec or Ardent Custodian and Ageis of the scarlet commander as protection spec?

Kommentar von Thottbot

Dos this spell benifit from normal critt rating and spell critt rating just as HoW, or is it just on spell?

Kommentar von Allakhazam

I cannot use this spell and I have no idea why. I activate seal of the and it simply says "you can't do that yet." Please help out folks

Kommentar von Allakhazam

you have to get behind them

Kommentar von gamedisciple

I noticed today while leveling that Richturteil isn't on the global cooldown.

That's pretty cool since now I can just put my judgement and seal on a macro and get my seal back up instantly when I judge it. Here's an example:

/cast Judgement
/cast Seal of Righteousness
/startattack

My only issue is that if I'm out of range of the target, I end up popping the seal again, but it's a small price to pay for convenience!

If you found this useful, please upvote!

Links

Richturteil

Richturteil

5% von Grundmana	10 Meter Reichweite

Sofort	8 sek. Abklingzeit

Entfesselt die Energie eines Siegels, um einen Gegner zu richten und so Heiligschaden zu verursachen.

Zauberdetails

Dauer

n/a

Magieart

Heilig

Mechanik

n/a

Bannart

n/a

GCD-Kategorie

Normal

Kosten

5% von Grundmana

Reichweite

10 Meter (Sehr kurz)

Zauberzeit

Sofort

Abklingzeit

8 sekunden

GCD

1.5 sekunden

Effekt

Dummy
Wert: 3 (AP mod:0.36)
PVP-Multiplikator: 1
Serverseitiges Skript

Flags

Kann nicht verwendet werden, während Ihr gestaltverwandelt seid
Waffe nicht wegstecken
Initiiere Kampf (aktiviert Auto-Attack)
Wirker-Procs unterdrücken
Verwickelt das Ziel nicht in einen Kampf
Keine autmatische Zielwahl bei Anfängerkampf
Angriff nicht ausweichen
Angriff nicht parrieren
Angriff nicht blocken

Richturteil

Stärkungszauber

Zauberdetails

Weiteres

Beitragen