Kommentare

Kommentar von Koper

Part of the 4.2 quest chain; you'll need 1000 of those to make the legendary staff. Also see Herz der Flamme.(##RESPBREAK##)12##DELIM##Gnub##DELIM##Koper still dreams about Atiesh, Hohestab des Wächters, and as thus he accidentally wrote 60 instead of 25 - which was then changed to 1000.

Kommentar von Dewthelock

It requires 25 not 60. http://db.mmo-champion.com/q/29270/time-grows-short/

Kommentar von bassamradi52

i really wonder if there is a specific class who can use it like Shadowmourne.

Kommentar von wutangvscapcom

Is it possible the 25 man route to obtaining the staff will require 25 of these and the 10 man route will require 60?

Blizzard in the past has indicated that 25 man raids should obtain the legendary roughly 2.5 times faster (or 2.5 times as many made) in comparison to 10 man raids.

Most recently however they have indicated that both 25 man and 10 man raids will obtain the legendary at roughly the same pace

Note that 60/25 = ~2.5

I hope more data becomes available soon

Kommentar von 576573

From Ask the Devs #4:

Q: How do you plan on normalizing Legendary weapon aquisition rate between 10 man and 25 man raids? If the drop rate is the same for 'shards' in 10 and 25 man raids, this may 'force' 25 man guilds to run 2-3 10 mans in order to maximize shard/legendary aquisition. If the drop rate for 'shards' in 25 man raids was 2.5 times than that in 10 man, it could take a 10 man guild say, 2.5 months to gain a legendary whereas a 25 man guild would take 1 month. - Deathsaint (NA/ANZ)

A: Our main goal is to offer the Legendary in both 10 and 25 without requiring say a 25-player raid to feel like they have to switch to running 10s for the sole purpose of Legendary fragment acquisition (and the same is true for 10s). Our plan is to make Legendary completion take longer to acquire in 10-player raids. The exact ratio will be somewhat obfuscated because of the variation in the amount of fragments dropped per boss based on both raid size and raid difficulty. However, you can plan on it being maybe 2 to 2.5 times faster for the 25-player raid. It should feel analogous to number of Valor points or gold dropped in 25s, and is being treated the same.

Kommentar von Igniz

Erm, he says specifically that 10m raids will take longer.

Kommentar von 717743

Do these also drop off bosses like Eternal Embers do once players have reached this part of the quest line?

Kommentar von 264294

Are these simply quest items that everybody on the quest can pick up or are they master looted?

Kommentar von 850859

Just killed Heroic Shannox 10m.

I got 25 cinders DX
this is gonna take 6-7 lockouts on 10m.

Kommentar von thewhistler

ragnaros normal 10 man = 19 cinders ;(

Kommentar von Runawaynow

I'll keep track of the cinders I see in our 10 man raid here in case Wowhead continues to not differentiate between difficulties and raid sizes :) Thus this post may be updated between Tuesday and Thursday with new numbers each week. Yay stats.

Week 3 our "staff-getter" was unable to show up one day, hence dashes...
Week 5 our "staff-getter" had some drama and decided not to show up. You guessed it....dashes...
Week 7 the numbers became not accurate to the progress values, which are accurate. How odd... It's possible that "staff-getter 1" went into the alt raid on Week 5 whereupon he net 36 cinders (18 + 18) which evens out the values.
Week 8 "Staff-getter 1" was unable to siphon Essences from Alysrazor and Majordomo. Very interesting...
Week 9 Achievements week, last week of maintaining updates to cinder drop counts. I believe we have successfully established the correct values for the ranges :)

Heroic kills in bold

Boss	Wk 1	Wk 2	Wk 3	Wk 4	Wk 5	Wk 6	Wk 7	Wk 8	Wk 9
Shannox	25	26	--	24	24	26	25	26	23
Beth'tilac	20	19	--	22	--	18	20	26	18
Alysrazor	22	22	--	23	24	26	23	25	21
Lord Rhyolith	23	21	23	25	24	26	26	24	20
Baleroc	23	20	21	20	--	24	25	26	25
Majordomo	23	23	22	24	--	26	25	26	24
Ragnaros	19	19	20	23	--	22	20	23
Totals	155	150	86	161	72	168	164

Progress

Staff-getter #1	Completed
Staff-getter #2
Staff-getter #3
Staff-getter #4

It is becoming apparent from these stats as well as scattered reports of drop counts and difficulties on this page and others, as well as Wowhead data (which does not denote any raid sizes or difficulties) that the following ranges are represented:

10 Man	25 Man
Normal	18-23	48-55
Heroic	23-26	55-66

Kommentar von 499393

Started collecting cinders in 10man last night.
Normal modes on each boss.

21/22/18/22/19/22 total of 124 Cinders.
Ragnaros still up.

Kommentar von Karneg

I only got 113 Cinders with Ragnaros still up. (10man/normal for all boss)
So I guess we had bad luck this week :(

Last week was 149, btw. (10man/ normal full clear)
Even considering "Runawaynow" is doing H. Shannox, I think he/her is extremely lucky.

Kommentar von 714798

So not equipping the staff will still work?

Kommentar von hitmehard

If you like a reminder of this quest part after completing it;
Any excess Seething Cinder's past one thousand are kept after the quest hand in.

Kommentar von Munkie986

Is the information:

10 Man

Normal------18-23
Heroic -------23-26

25 Man

Normal------48-55
Heroic ------55-66

Provided by: Runawaynow's post, Still accurate for 25man? I can confirm the Heroic 10man is still accurate (did 6/7 HM FL last night and got 23-26 per boss, with a total of 148 at the end of the night form the 6 bosses averaging to 24.66~ per boss).

3D-Ansicht Bessere Gegenstände finden...Links

Kurzübersicht

Screenshots

Videos

Siedende Schlacke

Weiteres

Beitragen